In order to prevent such capital arbitrage by banks, the revised market risk. Some trading operations try to anticipate and place bets ahead of major marketmoving events. Regulatory capital arbitrage for beginners the baseline. If such a switch happens, the difference in capital will be recorded as a pillar 1 capital surcharge. Banks claim this will make hedging more costly and could incentivise the industry to keep risk in the. The order books of trading exchanges are often hidden as socalled dark pools.
A trading book is the portfolio of financial instruments held by a brokerage or bank. Concise in explanation yet comprehensive in scope, it provides an integrated overview of both the practices and the possibilities of the modern equity arbitrage. The trading book is required under basel ii and iii to be marked to market daily. The word arbitrage itself comes from the french word for judgment. Banks are strictly prohibited from reallocating an instrument in the trading book into the banking book for regulatory arbitrage benefits.
Differences between interest rate risk irr in the banking and. What is the difference between a banking book and a. Current rules have allowed banks to allocate transactions to trading book largely based on the intent to trade or to hedge. The precise answer is both complex and involves considerable latitude for opinion. Reassigning assets between books requires explicit approval of the regulator based on. Whitepaper interest rate risk in the banking book irrbb. Program issues and impacts impact of the trading book banking book boundary regulators are establishing a more objective boundary to mitigate capital arbitrage between the regulatory trading. How does a bank profit from arbitrage by moving assets. In particular, loans that would have been charged for credit risk, at oneyear 99. Close the loop hole of capital arbitrage between the trading book and the banking book calculate the capital for the trading book and the banking book as if the banks are in stressed market conditions calculate capital using the continue reading trading book and banking book. The measure was taken to avoid apparent market manipulation strategies executed by traders back then. Each position on an asset belongs to a book, being trading or a banking book.
Regulators have seen principles based approach to allocate transactions to a trading or a banking book as a source of capital arbitrage for the banks. Standardized minimum capital requirement mcr based on two metrics, the economic value of. Implications and actions for banks nevertheless, a number of banks have expressed the concern that frtb will lead to a significant increase in capital requirements which, combined with higher compliance costs, could decrease banking profitability. Financial instruments in a trading book are purchased or sold for reasons including to. Trading book and banking book treatment in frtb can be summarized in three lines as follows. If however, you have a seller of a rare comic book on the phone, and also have a buyer on the phone, and you can make a profit by buying and selling at the same time that is arbitrage. Which such arbitrage manipulation strategies are possible if the order book is public. What the basel proposals on bank tradingbook rules mean. Review of the trading book or frtb are designed to address basel 2. Calculate the capital for the trading book and the banking book as if the banks are in stressed market conditions.
Banks see clash in basels trading and banking book work. Capital arbitrage is mitigated by imposing strict limits on the movement of instruments between books, and, if the capital charge on an instrument or portfolio is reduced as a result of. A revised boundary between the trading book and banking book establishment of a more objective boundary will serve to reduce incentives to arbitrage between the regulatory banking and trading books, while still being aligned with banks risk management practices. Rbc25 boundary between the banking book and the trading book. With the interest rate risk of the banking book, the basel committee on banking supervision bcbs 1 aims primarily to address the potential loss of economic value of institutions from a change in the interest rates called irr and credit spread risk csr in the banking book 2. The difference between the trading and banking book blogger. The current boundary is subjective intent to trade and hence difficult to police and susceptible to arbitrage. The valueatrisk var for assets in the trading book is measured on a. Overview of the revised internal models approach for market risk. Trading book assets are traditionally markedtomarket on timely basis whereas the banking book. It can change the regulatory capital the bank must set aside against the asset, so it is sometimes called a regulatory ar. In his post, kling said, in retrospect, this is a bit like watching a movie in which a jailer becomes sympathetic to a prisoner, when we know that the prisoner is eventually going to escape. Real estate holdings and retail and small business lending must go in the banking book.
The valueatrisk for assets in the trading book is measured on a tenday time horizont under basel ii. Frtb still builds on the intent based criteria for tradingbanking book. Trading book vs banking book banks are required to divide their balance sheets between banking and trading books both from regulatory and accounting perspective. Revised trading and banking book boundary for market risk 11 total sample. The really brief version imo is that, basically, banks could regulatory arbitrage by shifting from the banking book to the trading book. The reallocation of securities between trading and banking book should be considered a reassignment of securities and is governed by rbc25.
Tougher boundary between a bank s trading book and its banking book to reduce regulatory arbitrage. An expressed purpose of the regulation is to avoid regulatory arbitrage between banking and trading book. A bank is running a matched book when the maturities of its assets and liabilities are equally distributed. But zen arbitrage has builtin amazon trade in credit search tools, and this is just one of just four ways you can make money with zen arbitrage, the worlds first online book arbitrage tool. Moving an asset from banking book to trading book cannot generate any profit, its a pure regulatory accounting transaction.
Basel iv revised trading and banking book boundary for. The secret formula the 7 ingredients of a book that can be flipped on amazon. Close the loop hole of capital arbitrage between the trading book and the banking book. For a complete list of beginners articles, see financial crisis for beginners arnold kling helpfully pointed out a 2000 paper on regulatory capital arbitrage by david jones, an economist at the fed. The trading book is an accounting term that refers to assets held by a bank that are regularly traded. In the financial markets, the general assumption is that, at least in the short run, the market price is the right price. The basel committee is concerned about the risk of arbitrage between trading and banking book classifications. Proprietary traders may use a variety of strategies such as index arbitrage, statistical arbitrage, merger arbitrage. Arbitrage using the infinite banking concept an infinite. The idea is that the arbitrageur arbitrates among the prices in the market to reach one final level. Amazon textbook tradein credit book arbitrage with zen. The trading book should be used by banks ideally only to incorporate assets which are held for trading as opposed to being held till maturity for example, any derivative instrument used as a speculative or arbitrage tool to earn profits. This would prevent lenders from shifting assets between books.
The basel committee on banking supervision bcbs wants to make banks treat the assets in their trading books more like those in their banking books by forcing them to hold increased capital against assets designated for trading historically, lower capital requirements for trading book assets had encouraged banks to shift assets from the more expensive banking book into the trading book. So far, the banks have been deciding if a book was a trading book or a banking book, and there was an incentive to arbitrage from this determination, as. Can you give us a very brief overview of the trading book and banking book. If a bank does an interest rate swap with a customer, thats trading book. Switching trades in order to gain regulatory arbitrage effects as well as capital benefits. So far, the banks have been deciding if a book was a trading book or a banking book, and there was an incentive to arbitrage from this determination, as there was a difference in the capital requirements for these books. The revised boundary between banking book and trading book shall deliver objectivity and reduce arbitrage. Bcbs committee guidelines have different risk computation treatment for banking and trading book. Banks must fair value daily any trading book instrument and recognise.
Arbitrage happens all the time with online trading because the. Trading book should contains all trades that are traded with intent of making profit through market price movement, hold for short term resale, lock in arbitrage profit or to hedge other trading book. To reduce the incentives for this, it has defined a less permeable boundary with. Exactly how to find book gold how to search amazon for book arbitrage gold.
Through the frtb rules, bcbs is seeking, for example, to establish a. The trading book refers to assets held by a bank that are available for sale and hence regularly traded. The valueatrisk var for assets in the trading book is measured on a 10day time horizon under basel ii. Proprietary trading also prop trading occurs when a trader trades stocks, bonds, currencies, commodities, their derivatives, or other financial instruments with the firms own money, aka the nostro account, contrary to depositors money, in order to make a profit for itself. The trading book is required under basel ii and iii to be markedtomarket on a daily basis. Basel capital rules for banks trading books will shift. Through the frtb rules, bcbs is seeking, for example, to establish a more objective boundary between the trading book and the banking book, and to eliminate capital arbitrage between the regulatory banking and trading books. Finding hidden profit in the worlds biggest book source how the biggest source of books to resell isnt a library book sale its amazon. Securities and financial contracts that a bank intends to trade, resell or profit from on. The complete arbitrage deskbook is the only book to combine operational details with practical analysis of modern equity arbitrage. What is the difference between the trading book and the banking book of a bank. Close the loop hole of capital arbitrage between the trading book and the banking book calculate the capital for the trading book and the banking book as if the banks are in stressed market conditions. A trading book is defined as positions which the bank holds for the purpose of short term gain and which it. However under frtb this principles based approach will go away and will.
374 1306 1141 1089 716 121 397 591 1046 746 647 1529 501 648 1455 554 660 409 538 1033 421 1464 1449 192 1376 521 1264 807 353 764 1082 669 1276 401 1407 1247 140 641 65 1371