The question is explored from diverse and radical perspectives. Bede rundle, why there is something rather than nothing. Or at least know why there was something rather than nothing in 1995. Now, applying this to the question why is there something rather than nothing. Why there is something rather than nothing book, 2006. The main characters of this science, non fiction story are. Sadly, the author had not, at the time of writing, got his head around wittgenstein, who is omitted. Krauss, initially published on january 10, 2012 by free press. Even the last remaining trump card of the theologian, why is there something rather than nothing. Why there is something rather than nothing free press, 2012. New scientist krauss possesses a rare talent for making the hardest ideas in astrophysics accessible to the layman, due in part to his sly humor one has to hope that this book wont appeal only to the partisans of the culture wars its just too good and. Cosmologist lawrence krauss discusses his book a universe from nothing. And finally, why is there something rather than nothing.
Science will never explain why theres something rather. I mean, my standard is george gamow, and you come very. He cites happenings at the quantum level to dispense with the need for god. There is something rather than nothing because there is something rather than nothing. Why there is something rather than nothing by lawrence krauss is excellent guide to cuttingedge physics. A universe from nothing why there is something rather than. Was the entire existence absent at some point in the past. Krauss, a wellknown cosmologist and prolific popularscience writer, apparently means to announce to the world, in this new book, that the laws of. What seems like a possibility to me is that a thing exists if it is a grouping, or something that ties stuff together into a unit whole.
Thats the question posed and answered by theoretical physicist lawrence krauss in a universe from nothing. In this stimulating and wellwritten book, oxford philosopher bede rundle tries to. Lawrence m krauss theoretical physicist lawrence krauss explains the groundbreaking new scientific advances presenting the most recent evidence for how our universe evolvedand the implications for how its going to. Why there is something rather than nothing book, 2004. Why there is something rather than nothing pdf epub book. Thats the question cosmologist lawrence krauss tackles in his new book, a universe from nothing. The recipient of numerous awards, krauss is a regular columnist for newspapers and magazines, including the new. By this, if there is a grouping defining what is contained within, this grouping is an existent entity. Its an odd question that could be thought of as either supremely profound, or supremely silly. Trying to make the cosmos out of nothing new scientist. Nov 11, 2016 the explanation he gave was that god wanted to create a universe the best one possible which makes god the simple reason that there is something rather than nothing. From the beginning of our universe to its end, this book is sure to delight. Dec 11, 2007 polish philosopher leszek kolakowskis why is there something rather than nothing 23 questions from great philosophers was supposed to be longer. Free download or read online a universe from nothing.
Although heidegger described this as the fundamental question of metaphysics, the answer is quite straightforward at its base, if we are strictly examining a comparison between something and nothing. Why there is something rather than nothing ebook written by lawrence m. Atheism, i present three arguments for the existence of god. Physicist lawrence krauss peddles this message in his new book a universe from nothing. Lawrence krauss why is there something rather than nothing. I cannot get beyond his argument that there could not have been nothing, which is intriguing. But even if you believe in god, theres still a problem, because if god is a something rather than nothing, then its not an answer at all. To get us started thinking about it, lets distinguish between reasons and causes. If gods existence precedes the cosmos, and gods will is sufficient to bring a physical universe into existence, then weve just pushed the question back a level.
Its hard to know what an answer might even look like. One is the moral argument, which shows that if god does not exist then objective moral facts such as it is wrong to torture babies for fun cannot exist. Why theres something rather than nothing the washington. Today, exciting scientific advances provide new insight into this cosmological mystery. Why there is something rather than nothing from the worlds largest community of readers. Buy why there is something rather than nothing by rundle, bede isbn. For why something rather than nothing, i more and more have come to believe that theres always been something, theres always been the cosmos, the single and only physical entity of which we are all a part. Try to imagine a book without a surface defining what is contained within. Frank wilczek, nobel laureate and herman feshbach professor at mit with characteristic wit, eloquence, and clarity lawrence krauss gives a wonderfully illuminating account of how science deals with one of the biggest. In his book a universe from nothing, krauss seeks to answer the ageold question, why is there something rather than nothing without reference to god. It discusses modern cosmogony and its implications for the debate about the existence of god. Krauss says the cause of the universe is not godit is nothing. Sep 12, 20 an engaging speaker and winsome personality, dr. Bede rundle why there is something rather than nothing offers an explanation of fundamental facts of existence in purely philosophical terms, without appeal either to theology or cosmology.
By way of an answer, leibniz appealed to what has become a popular strategy. Why there is something rather than nothing by lawrence krauss is an excellent guide to new physics. Why there is something rather than nothing free press, 2012, by cosmologist lawrence m. Kolakowski treats each philosopher with great respect though, admittedly, some more than others his handling of nietzsche in particular can verge on the testily paternal. New scientist with its mindbending mechanics, krauss argues, our universe may indeed have appeared from nowhere, rather than at the hands of a divine creator. God is the reason the universe exists, but gods existence is its own reason, since god exists necessarily. When i picked up this book, i thought there would be a series of arguments answering the question asked in the title of the book, instead there is a number of thumb nail sketches of philosophers starting with socrates going through husserl. In this clear and crisply written book, lawrence krauss outlines the compelling evidence that our complex cosmos has evolved from a hot, dense state and how. Trying to prove logically that the question is nonsensical. Lawrence krauss, a renowned theoretical physicist, is director of the origins project at arizona state university. Jim holt explores the interzone between philosophy and scientific cosmology in trying to answer an ancient question. Bestselling author and acclaimed physicist lawrence krauss offers a paradigmshifting view of how everything that exists came to be in the first place.
Frank wilczek, nobel laureate and herman feshbach professor at mit, author of the lightness of being. Krauss is a theoretical physicist and professor at arizona state university. A universe from nothing npr coverage of a universe from nothing. Why there is something rather than nothing is a nonfiction book by the physicist lawrence m.
Why the universe exists why, indeed, there is anything at all is the kind of question that often first piques our philosophical interest. Krauss spends most of his book redefining nothing in terms of increasingly incorporeal somethings from empty space to reified laws of physics, as if this justified the conclusion that literal nothingness could be the cause of the cosmos. It is a question almost all of us have been struck by at some point or other. Olsson, lund university the question, why is there something rather than nothing. For why something rather than nothing, i more and more have come to believe that theres. Why is there something rather than nothing 23 questions. The main theme of the book is how we have discovered that all signs suggest a universe that could and plausibly did arise from a deeper nothinginvolving the absence of space itself andwhich may one day return to.
The first edition of the novel was published in 2012, and was written by lawrence m. One of the few prominent scientists today to have actively crossed the chasm between science and popular culture, krauss reveals that modern science is addressing the question of why there is something rather than nothing, with surprising and fascinating results. Some philosophers conclude why is there something rather than nothing. Welcome,you are looking at books for reading, the a universe from nothing why there is something rather than nothing, you will able to read or download in pdf or epub books and notice some of author may have lock the live reading for some of country. Its very difficult to explain something that doesnt make any sense i guess that would mean im not enlightened, so i opted for a long quote which explains it better than i can. Conversely, the probability of there being something is as close to one as you can get. Apr 23, 2012 physicist lawrence krauss peddles this message in his new book a universe from nothing. To investigate this question holt consulted many of. God might very well be a bottomup rather than a topdown phenomenon natural. The book is denser than i had expected, and i felt at times he was too much labouring to make a point.
The explanation he gave was that god wanted to create a universe the best one possible which makes god the simple reason that there is something rather than nothing. Bestselling author and acclaimed physicist lawrence krau. Why is there stu why is there anything inside the universe, rather than just empty. Where did the 400 billion or so galaxies come from, exactly. A questionbegging, circular, and ultimately confused argument. However, their explanation takes science and turns it on its headperforming miracles of creation through unknown physics or mechanisms that are extremely unlikely to occur. Review of bede rundles why there is something rather than.
What i think is that in order to answer the question why is there something rather than nothing. A universe from nothing why there is something rather than nothing by lawrence krauss audiobook. Thus the initial probability of there being nothing rather than something is one divided by infinity, which is next to nothing, a virtual zero. In fact nothing is something and nothing is unstable. The question, why is there something rather than nothing. Why there is something rather than nothing is a book by physicist lawrence m. Polish philosopher leszek kolakowskis why is there something rather than nothing 23 questions from great philosophers was supposed to be longer. Lawrence krauss the colbert report video clip comedy. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read a universe from nothing.
Why there is something rather than nothing by lawrence m. A universe from nothing why there is something rather than nothing. Right now im halfway through jim holts terrific book why does the world exist. However it is a comprehensive work, and i am glad to have read nearly finished it. May 14, 20 or at least know why there was something rather than nothing in 1995. They think the question stumps us by imposing an impossible explanatory demand, namely, deduce the existence of something without using any existential premises.
The climax is a bold scientific answer to the great question of existence. He suggests that people who ask the question usually mean how is there something. Thats the big question were asking in this weeks show. Indeed, the question, why is there something rather than nothing. A slight and deceptively modest volume, why is there something rather than nothing. The book was published in multiple languages including english, consists of 204 pages and is available in hardcover format. Why there is something rather than nothing 9780199270507. Nov, 2007 a slight and deceptively modest volume, why is there something rather than nothing. Why there is something rather than nothing a universe from nothing.
In his brilliant book a universe from nothing, lawrence krauss develops the idea of selfcreating universes. Lawrence krauss talks about quantum mechanics, god and the various types of nothingness. This question, usually thought to fall strictly within the purview of philosophy and theology, has recently received attention in the world of popular science thanks to books by stephen hawking and lawrence m. Why there is something rather than nothing is a non fiction book by the physicist lawrence m. Not how the world is, is the mystical, but that it is. In elegant and accessible prose, the eminent philosopher leszek kolakowski explores the essence of these ideas and their ongoing relevance as he introduces us to the great figures of western thought. Science will never explain why theres something rather than.
Reflecting on the great issues that animate our livesgood and evil, truth and. Jan, 2012 lawrence krauss new book a universe from nothing. Therefore it need a free signup process to obtain the book. Mar 25, 2012 look at how richard dawkins sums it up in his afterword. Krauss has written a book for the lay reader about the latest developments in. This groundbreaking volume investigates the most fundamental question of all. Philosopher brian leftow has argued that the question cannot have a causal explanation as any cause must itself have a cause or a contingent explanation as the factors giving the contingency must preexist, and that if there is an answer it must be something that exists necessarily i. He is the author of more than 300 scientific publications and nine books, including the international bestsellers, a universe from nothing and the physics of star trek.
1375 1453 1027 322 765 150 718 286 73 437 297 599 329 970 1407 245 709 1011 1238 605 143 526 1230 871 1488 510 1551 153 473 121 845 980 1167 1022 487 1109 243 1419